Thoroughly describe your own experiences and the responses
of your partners to the experiment. Did you find this assignment easy or
difficult and why? Did your partners alter the way they communicated with you
because of your absence of communication? Describe.
As I came across the instructions
that we would not be able to talk seemed difficult as at sight but soon after I
saw it as a cool experiment seeing what would be the reaction of my friends.
When I first decided to conduct the experiment I took to account that I would
need to make it as effective as I could so that I could get the results I want,
so I decided to start the experiment within a conversation I started with
multiple friends. During the experiment my friends thought I was joking the
whole time trying to be funny joking about how I wasn’t talking because they
didn’t think it would be an assignment.
Who was in control of the conversation, you or your partner?
Who initiated or changed topics? Who asked and who answered questions? If you
conducted this experiment with more than one person, were you ever excluded
from the conversation? If you think of a conversation as a balance of power
between two (or more) individuals, who had the power in this conversation, you
or your partner? Explain your answer.
At first I was in control of the
conversation then I decided to randomly stop talking to see what my friends
would do. Soon after I would keep the conversation going with just head
movements nodding yes or no or shrugging indicating that I agreed with them or
simply trying to keep the conversation going for the experiment. Since I
conducted this with multiple friends I was excluded from them, their body
directions shifted inwards to each other rather than to me as it was. They felt
and look annoyed of me even just being there nodding as they talked. I then
would walk in between them so that they could see I was still trying to
communicate with them. It was interesting to see that I still had the power in
the conversation because they were still interested in what I was doing or what
expressions I would have. In a sense my body language was more important
because it was unpredictable and they had to pay more attention since they
couldn’t see me.
Imagine that you and your partners in the conversation
represent two different cultures, one that uses spoken language and one that
doesn’t. Which culture has the advantage in communicating complex ideas within
their population? What attitudes might the speaking culture have toward the
culture that does not use symbolic language? Can you identify any modern
situations that mirror or resemble this relationship between a culture that can
speak and culture that can’t?
The culture speaking the spoken
language has the advantage in communicating its complex idea within the
population because they know the language. The speaking culture doesn’t
struggle to communicate therefore its attitude towards the population might be
the same within each other since they don’t have any complications. As for the
culture that doesn’t use the language, they can be looked at as less powerful
put at a disadvantage when trying to communicate with them. For example if the
job is English speaking and the person trying to acquire the job speaks a
foreign language. Modern situations that might resemble this relation between
cultures is within the Hispanic community trying to adapt to an American
culture. They will talk try to say words similar to English words in an attempt
to communicate as well as using body language to help demonstrate the word.
Thoroughly
describe your own experiences and the responses of your partners to the experiment.
Did you find this assignment easy or difficult and why? How did your partner(s)
respond to your lack of body language? Did they have any difficulty
understanding you? Describe.
I found this experiment difficult
in the sense that I couldn’t move. Although it was easier than the first part
because I was able to talk, at the beginning of the experiment it was difficult
trying not to move. I would fail but soon after I tried harder but at some
points still rose my eyebrows. It was difficult but this experience shows how
not only do we communicate with words but we communicate with physical language
as well as expression. My friends described my body language as awkward towards
the end of the conversation because I only talked with my mouth. My partners as well thought it was difficult
although they thought it was funny how I looked stiff talking. They as well thought it was interesting and
decided to try it but as expected it wasn’t easy.
What does this experiment say about
our use of “signs” in our language, i.e., how important is nonspeech language
techniques in our ability to communicate effectively? What type of information
do humans receive about the words a person is speaking when they “read” a
person’s body language?
What this experiment says is that
“signs” also go with our spoken language. Moving our body as we talk is
natural, it is something we don’t think of doing and helps shows emotion. When a person shows body language it shows a
lot about the person. For example if a person is in a conversation and they
start to shake their legs or tap their fingers this might indicate that the
person is nervous. As well as if a person is scratching their head in a
conversation this can give out that they are stressing over something or they
are trying too hard to think. I have also noticed when professional speakers talk
to the public for example in the news, they will talk more clearly and there
face expressions will change depending on the tone they have. Usually the tone
of their voice as well as expression has to do with the type of news they have whether
it’s sad, tragic, or happy. Also, this
experiment taught me a little of what it might have been like being a hominid
trying to communicate because they lacked verbal communication and there for
had to talk with their body language.
Describe the adaptive
benefit to possessing the ability to read body language. How might the ability
to read body language help a person survive, obtain resources, and reproduce
successfully?
The benefit of possessing the
ability to read body language is important in many factors. You are able to
gather emotion and pick up other details you might have not picked up from the
person through their body language. For example, this can help you when you are
talking to a girl/guy you might like. Often times reading each other’s body language
can give each other hints on if you are interested or not. A way it can help a
person obtain resources is when someone goes down to a car dealership. Usually
when a person shows interest in a car the person lets out excitement and its
body language is easily read by the car salesman letting him know that you are interested.
By this he will make you overspend for the car. Making him acquire more money
for his commission.
Are there people who have difficulty reading body language
and can you identify them? Can you describe a situation where there might be a
benefit to not reading someone’s body language, i.e., a situation where perhaps
body language does not give you reliable information?
I think most people can read body
language because it is part of our way of communicating without us realizing
it. We read body language on day to day bases even if we aren’t talking we are
still able to tell what a person might feel. This has to do with judging a
person, it involves being able to read body language. An example of a way body
language is used is within dogs. Dogs are able to read body language from a
person and it tells them if the person is afraid or as well as if the person is
of harm to them. It will allow them to be ready to attack. As for an example
where body language might not be so beneficial is in a poker table. We all have
heard of the expression of having a “poker face.” This has to do with showing
little to no body language so other players won’t know when you have a good
hand or a bad hand.
Very good description of your first experiment with good detail. Interesting (and brave) that you chose to do this with a group of people without explaining it to them first. You replicated what you would actually find in the real world if you were a non-speaking person facing a group of speaking people.
ReplyDeleteI'm not clear on your conclusions for the section on power and control. You may have initially had control, but did you retain that control? If they had just decided to walk away from the setting, would you have been able to continue the experiment? How might this have worked if you tried it on complete strangers?
Good conclusion on the issue of communicating complex ideas and with your example of a real-life situation that mirrors the conditions of the experiment.
Good description of your second experiment and you were very thoughtful on your discussion as to the information we receive from body language and the benefits we achieve. That said, you are still just considering a situation where the body language confirms and supports the spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section as well).
You don't actually answer the first part of the question in the fourth section regarding people who have difficulty reading body language. There are groups of people who have great difficulty or an outright inability to read body language due to physical or mental disability, such as those who are in the autism spectrum or those who are blind (though they can read vocal intonation).
The poker example is a situation where it is to your advantage to not show body language. The question asks about a situation where it would be better to not READ body language. So when might body language of others mislead you and it would be better to ignore it? Do all cultures use the same system of body language? If you travel to another country, can you trust the information you get from their body language?
I agree with you about how the second experiment was a bit more difficult due to the fact that you were unable to use your hands but it was also easier than the first experiment because you were actually able to talk. I also agree that it may seem awkward or even a bit frustrating at times when you are only able to use your words and not your body language.
ReplyDeleteI was just commenting on another classmate's blog that my friends had partners that eventually excluded them from their conversation as well. I thought that was so interesting. It is almost like if people feel like they cannot communicate the way that they feel most comfortable, they will just tune you out. Clearly we are on to something if it has been happening to multiple sets of people!
ReplyDelete