Thursday, February 11, 2016

Blog Post: Historical Influences on Darwin

As we might know Charles Darwin was one of the many people who took on the challenge of evolution. One of the people who had a significant impact on Darwin's theory of natural selection is Jean-Baptiste Lamarck. Lamarck's theory on evolution was that all species change in an effort to adapt to their environment. For example, if an organ had not been used as much in the past and is now necessary in order to adapt in their environment, by exercising this organ it starts to grow throughout the species existence. This influenced Darwin and later helped him come up with a better conclusion that those who learn to adapt to their environment develop a dominate offspring needed to survive. Those who cant survive die off and only the dominate offspring remain within the species (Lamarck vs Darwin).

According to Lamarck, evolution is a change through generations at which inherit the necessary dominate organism to survive depending on the environment.  Lamarck was able to prove this within many species for example giraffes. Having had studied many giraffe fossils, Lamarck saw that previous ancestors not always had long necks. He concluded that long necks become a necessity in order to reach their new food found in their new environment. This had a positive affect on Darwin since it helped him continue his study which later helped him concluded that giraffes inherit the offspring in a later generation resulting into longer necks which could explain his theory of natural selection.

Darwin might have had helped from Lamarck since they both had teamed up at one point but Darwin could have still come to his conclusion of natural selection. When Darwin and Lamarck met to collaborate, both of their research findings were identical. Both Darwin and Lamarck proved their findings in different species, Darwin saw his findings through elephant trunks and Lamarck from giraffes. The way I see Lamarck's influence on Darwin was that he made is gave him more evidence to prove his point.

The attitude of the church might have discouraged Darwin into publishing his working about evolution. Specially at that time at which the church was always seen as the leader to answers. By publishing the book, Darwin might have to second think it.

3 comments:

  1. I definitely agree with you that Jean-Baptiste Lamarck was Charles Darwin's largest influence. I enjoy your line answering the last question of the assignment "church was always seen as the leader to answers". Next time watch out for punctuation! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I definitely agree with you that Jean-Baptiste Lamarck was Charles Darwin's largest influence. I enjoy your line answering the last question of the assignment "church was always seen as the leader to answers". Next time watch out for punctuation! :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. In general, good explanation for Lamark's theory. I do have some concerns about the connection you attempt to make with Darwin's theory:

    "This influenced Darwin and later helped him come up with a better conclusion that those who learn to adapt to their environment develop a dominate offspring needed to survive."

    Not quite. Let's start from the beginning...

    Lamarck was the first to propose an actual mechanism explaining "how" evolution occurred, not just "if" it occurred. This is a big deal and, although Lamarck's ideas turned out to be incorrect, this first step in evolutionary theory laid the path for those like Darwin to follow. Lamarck argued that organisms changed during their lifetimes in response to changes in their environment through the use or disuse of physical structures. Those physical changes were then passed onto their offspring. The classic example is the lengthening of the giraffe's neck in response to taller trees.

    Darwin argued instead that the environment doesn't cause individuals to change. Instead, he argued that within populations, there is existing variation. Within any given environment, some variations will be more successful than others at obtaining resources and reproducing more offspring. Those offspring will carry the more successful traits into the next generation, where the environment will again "select" the more successful variants and the pattern will continue, changing the population in response to the changing environment. Note that the populations is not "learning to adapt"... it just is adapting. It also isn't an issue of producing "dominant" offspring, just successful offspring. That term "dominant" means something very specific in genetics (next week's topic) and I want to make sure you use it correctly to avoid confusion.

    The second section was asking you to select the bullet points that applied to Lamarck's work. You seem to pick the points on the changing environment and this issue of heritability, both important points. A third point that is directly attributable to Lamarck is the issue of reproduction being required for evolution to occur.

    A point that is important because Lamarck and Darwin argued in direct opposition to each other is the idea that "Individuals don't evolve, populations do". Lamarck actually argued that individuals DO evolve. Darwin's mechanism didn't predict individual evolution as it acted on existing variation in the population. You can only see evolutionary change at the level of the population across generations, not within generations in an individual.

    "Darwin might have had helped from Lamarck since they both had teamed up at one point..."

    No! They didn't team up. Lamarck died in 1829. Darwin was only 20 at the time and just starting his studies to become an Anglican parson about that time.

    I'm concerned by comments you make that suggest that Lamarck was able to "prove" his theory. He didn't because his ideas were wrong. That doesn't mean that parts of his theory, namely the influence of the environment and the importance of inheritance and reproduction, weren't valuable to Darwin.

    A little more explanation is needed in the final section. Darwin delayed for more than 20 years before publishing. So what caused his delay? What were his concerns? What repercussions might he and his family have experienced as a result of publishing this controversial work in this scientific and religious environment?

    ReplyDelete